|
Film: |
Kurbaan |
| Directed By: |
Rensil D’Silva |
| Screenplay: |
Rensil D’Silva |
| Story: |
Karan Johar |
| Cinematographer: |
Hemant Chaturvedi |
| Editor: |
Asif Ali Shaikh |
| Dialogue: |
Anurag Kashyap, Niranjan Iyengar |
| Music: |
Salim - Sulaiman |
| Sound: |
Nakul Kamte |
| Cast: |
Saif Ali Khan, Kareena Kapoor, Vivek Oberoi, Om Puri, Kirron Kher & Spcial Appearances by Dia Mirza, Akash Khurana, Kulbhushan Kharbanda, Nauheed Cyrusi & Akash Khurana |
Kurbaan begins with a nice title sequence. After which we are in Delhi for a while as Professor Ehsaan (Saif Ali Khan) sweeps Professor Avantika (Kareena) off her feet. A whirlwind courtship happens between the two professors, both of whom behave more like students and one of whom even looks more a student than a professor. The film moves along at a good pace, so you don’t worry too much about professors necking in the college staff room, and concentrate instead on Ehsaan trying to convince Avantika’s Dad (Akash Khurana) that a difference in religions cannot come in the way of two people in love. Avantika is moving back to teaching in New York University, from where she’d taken a break to be with her ailing Dad in India. Ehsaan, the nice guy, offers to come along to be with her, so that she doesn’t have to give up a good career opportunity to be with him. Married and together, they are now in the favoured land of Dharma Productions, the US of A, hunting for a home and a job for Ehsaan. Thankfully, the pace doesn’t slacken now, and no one breaks into a song while showing us the wonderful sights of America.
Soon, the couple move into an Indian neighbourhood in suburban New York and Ehsaan gets a teaching job with remarkable ease, based on his wife’s recommendation, at the university where she teaches. Their Muslim neighbours invite them over for dinner and it is an uncomfortable visit as they discover that the women sit separately and it is a rather conservative household. The new bride still has stars in her eyes as life is going good but a visit by her neighbour Salma the next morning, saying that her life is in danger, brings in a note of unease. To Avantika’s consternation, Ehsaan thinks that they should not bother about their neighbour’s private problems. She is however too intrigued by the subsequent disappearance of Salma to not worry, and as she snoops, she stumbles into a sleeper terrorist cell. Worse, she is discovered and as she tries to save herself, she realizes that Ehsaan is one of them.
Avantika is not killed off immediately because she is now pregnant and Ehsaan wants the child. He is possible also not just a cold-blooded terrorist but has also fallen in love a bit. So, Avantika is under house arrest and there’s a threat to her Dad’s life to ensure that she stays in place. Meanwhile, a plane is blown up by one of their operatives and Riyaaz (Vivek Oberoi), a reporter, loses his reporter girlfriend (Dia Mirza), also a reporter who was traveling in that plane. As Riyaaz comes to know about Avantika’s plight and about the terrorist cell that blew up the plane, he rather unconvincingly decides to play sleuth without bringing in the FBI. He infiltrates the terrorist outfit and with Avantika’s help, he tries to stop the next big plan of a series of bomb explosions in New York subway stations. Well, not a very smart plan I guess, and leaves one wondering why he preferred it to going to the cops.
Some stories have blood in them and along with blood, a good pace and an engaging enough story, there are also lots and lots of loopholes. Ehsaan’s back story is not just a bit chronologically challenged, but we also never know why he is considered a dreaded terrorist or why the FBI doesn’t catch him since he is not just on their list but also looks more or less the same in their file photograph of his! Riyaaz or Avantika not trying to call the cops / FBI is not convincing and the FBI is shown as too less proactive. Why do terrorists leave doors unlocked for Avantika’s snooping convenience? Why do the terrorists not check into Riyaaz’s background? Why does Avantika use such a ‘filmi’ seducing ploy to snoop on Ehsaan? And last and most important, why does Bhaijaan (Om Puri) tell Ehsaan his secret plans since he had in the first place made these secret plans as he felt he could not trust Ehsaan?
While Kurbaan would have been a far superior film had these and some more loopholes not been allowed, I will not take it from the film that it still manages to be an engaging enough thriller. The Kareena –Saif chemistry is nice and the much talked about love scene actually exists and is not just a publicity gimmick! Vivek and the rest of the cast are all right too and the film has a nice look. A nice enough viewing, for a Bollywood take on the world of Islamic terrorism. Don’t expect anything more and you will not be disappointed.
Rating: ** Two stars out of five 
More Reviews
even in Ehsaan's personal life, there is a Hindu Avantika -cheated, under house arrest, 'at stake in every way'
anyway, don't want to start rambling-it's not so important.
but,
Intelligent review as always.
and
"..the favoured land of Dharma Productions.." made me smile.
no wonder then, that I read this page even as i am buried in unread Sunday papers.
a friend said it's a little ispired by Arlington road; is it, Irene?
Reply to this
It is indeed a little inspired by Arlington Road, and there's much more to crib about, including the scratching-on-the-surface discussions on Islamic fundamentalism, but I didn't want to bore everyone with a novel sized review.
Reply to this
Too many silly points in the movie for me to really enjoy it. Nice Review as always, Irene.
Reply to this
And thanks for dropping in Beyniaz
Reply to this
Is this a thriller or some lecture against 'fundamental' terrorist minds from Islam? I feel the story is tight, but then the loopholes may be 'coz the entire plot wasn't convincingly scrutinized.
Reply to this
Just plain ole bad writing Suvojit.
Reply to this
Hi Irene, Based on your review I think I’ll give this film a miss. I did have this sneaky feeling…Bollywood being what it is…doesn’t always paint a very realistic picture.
Reply to this
That would be the wise thing to do Mita
Reply to this
Hi Irene
The questions that u have raised - the same questions I used to bug my brother who was watching the movie with me.... I just found it so amusing n typical bollywood style.... with fbi having the file photo of saif n still not catching him was completely irrational... found the movie very disappointing n stretched (esp in the end)
good review, as usual
Reply to this
Thanks for reading Gagan
Reply to this
A good review,Irene as usual. Why don't they think of closing the obvious loopholes and tightening up the story !They are near yet so far.
Reply to this
Because big producers think they know all!
Reply to this
Nice tightly packed review Irene. Even if a wee bit filmy at least they are beginning to make movies on realistic issues. What about the love scene? Any better than the kiss and tell kind in our movies? Didn't expect that question eh?!
Reply to this
It was at least a bit like a love scene!
Reply to this
ok. atleast it was realistic.
Reply to this
Looks like people have started asking questions and it is nice that we have a movie that asks questions and is looking at a global issue. But don't know how this will be received in small towns and villages. Loved your honest review Irene. Maybe I will watch the movie for Bebo and Saif
Reply to this
The film isn't doing well and it was never meant for the smaller centres in nay case.
Reply to this
Nice review, Irene. How is the film doing at the box office?
Reply to this
Not too well Indrani
Reply to this